Blog
Gene Editing and God
Tuesday, November 19, 2019While most of us have been paying attention to sports and the political drama in Washington, a quiet medical revolution has been taking place. Since the sequencing of the human genome about 20 years ago, medical researchers have been using this newfound understanding to develop treatments for genetic disorders. These treatments employ what is known as gene editing. Gene editing involves the use of a virus or some other vector to remove a harmful mutation from a patient’s DNA and replace it with genes that will function correctly.
As abstract as this sounds, its consequences have been profound. This year alone, the FDA has approved genetic therapies for spinal muscular atrophy and cystic fibrosis. I know Christians whose children suffer from these afflictions. They are burdened both with the care of a medically fragile child (which is far more time-consuming and expensive than most of us can imagine) and, often, with the knowledge that their child’s disorder will lead to premature death. For those in such a position, the appearance of these transformative therapies must seem like a miraculous dawn of hope.
However, some brethren are uneasy with the moral and spiritual implications of genetic editing. Once we start monkeying around with DNA, haven’t we trespassed into areas that properly belong to God? Aren’t we defying His will? Also, how do we draw the line between genetic editing for these reasons and genetic editing for any reason? What’s the difference between curing SMA and creating a future NBA All-Star?
To answer these questions, I think we must consider the events of the first three chapters of Genesis. When God created Adam, he held within his seed the potential to give the vast diversity of mankind that we see across the globe. Every race, every individual difference, all of those things were part of God’s original intent. He saw all of them and pronounced them good. I will never be an NBA All-Star, but I still reflect God’s plan for mankind.
However, genetic disorders appear on the scene not in Genesis 1, but in Genesis 3. They are part of the curse that Adam’s sin invited. We die not because our deaths please Him and fulfill His will, but because our rebellion left Him with no other choice. If the wickedness of Adam’s first, long-lived, descendants was so great that God had to destroy the world with water, how wicked would we become with an eternity to perfect our wickedness?
I am skeptical of efforts to do a better job with God’s creation than He did, but I see no problem with fighting against sickness. Ultimately, such efforts will prove vain. Even children who have been relieved from the burden of genetic illness will someday die. However, if resisting the great enemy of humankind is wrong, then Jesus Himself was wrong. How many hopeless people did He heal?
Certainly, the technology used in genetic therapy can be abused, but I believe that the therapies themselves are something to celebrate. In this fallen world, even the innocent often suffer, but when we use understanding and skill to relieve their suffering, it is a godly act. I rejoice in the hope that genetic therapy offers to Jayden and Abigail and Sam and their families, as well as to many others whom I do not know. This is a new kind of healing, but it still comes from the One who gives all healing.
Summaries, Psalm 119:113-Psalm 120
Monday, November 18, 2019Psalm 119:113-120 (Samekh) shows more concern for the antics of evildoers. They anger the psalmist and he wants them to go away because he knows they also anger God. By contrast, the psalmist fears God’s word and trusts His promises.
Psalm 119:121-128 (Ayin) again reflects the psalmist’s concern for what is going to happen to him. He asks for protection from his enemies, the fulfillment of God’s promises, God’s love, greater understanding, and vindication. He compares the crookedness of the wicked to the uprightness of God’s law.
Psalm 119:129-136 (Pe) describes the glories of the word and the psalmist’s longing for them. He yearns for the commandments, and he wants God to be gracious to him because of his commitment to the law. To him, God’s word and God’s blessing go hand in hand.
Psalm 119:137-144 (Tsadhe) returns to the theme of the word’s perfection. God’s statutes have been established by Him, His promises have been tested and found to be true, and His law will always reveal what is righteous. Because of this, the psalmist is confident that through understanding them, he will live.
Psalm 119:145-152 (Qoph) reveals the psalmist’s behavior in trouble. He calls to God to rescue him, even rising before dawn to do so. Through the night, he continues to reflect on the word. As a result, he asks God to protect him from the wicked (who are far from the law), because of God’s nearness to the righteous.
Psalm 119:153-160 (Resh) reports the psalmist’s attitude toward God’s law and those who violate it. He remembers the law and God’s promise. Despite his many enemies, he continues to hold to it, and he regards those who do not with contempt. Ultimately, his hope is in the word.
Psalm 119:161-168 (Sin and Shin) presents the psalmist’s focus on the law. Even though powerful people are persecuting him, he gives it his attention. He rejoices at it and praises God for it. Because of his love for God’s testimonies, he obeys them.
Psalm 119:169-176 (Taw) contains the psalmist’s promise of faithfulness if God rescues him. He wants both deliverance from his enemies and greater understanding of the word. Because of his faithfulness, he asks God’s help, and he promises to praise Him and to continue to remember His commandments if he receives that help.
Psalm 120 is written from the perspective of an exile. He begins by praising God for His past help, and he then asks God to rescue him from people who are lying about him. He expresses the wish that the tongues of the liars will be pierced with arrows and burned with hot coals. In the meantime, the psalmist is stuck in Meshech, amid the tents of Kedar (basically, in the deserts of modern-day Iraq). Even though he wants peace, he’s surrounded by warmongers.
Authenticity and Following the Rules
Friday, November 15, 2019We live in an age that values authenticity above all else. It’s perfectly OK to practice whatever sin, so long as you’re Really You while you’re practicing it. Conversely, through the years I’ve heard a number of indictments of brethren as being Not Really Authentic. Supposedly, members of churches of Christ are the spiritual heirs of the Pharisees. They’re so focused on following the rules that they forget about loving God.
That’s never sat quite right with me, so I decided to put it to the test on that impartial arbiter of wisdom, Facebook. Is this actually a Scripturally intelligible concept? Anywhere in the Bible, do we see people who follow God’s rules without caring about Him?
When I posed this question on Facebook, it generated a great deal of discussion, but nobody could come up with a clear Biblical example. The Pharisees weren’t heartfelt followers of God, but they weren’t obedient either. Instead, they were hypocritical lovers of money who won their reputation through self-promotion. The church in Ephesus had left their first love despite having all sorts of good works, but the cure to their disease was still repenting and doing the works that they had done at first. And so on. It seems to be universally true in Scripture that everybody who has a heart problem has an obedience problem too.
On the other hand, being on fire for God, passionately sure that you’re doing what is right, showing everybody how much you care, does not appear to be a guarantee of righteousness. Saul of Tarsus thought he was doing good by zealously persecuting Christians. Apollos thought he was doing the right thing by preaching the baptism of John. Both learned that they had some changes to make.
It seems to me, then, that the cultural idol of authenticity isn’t actually a very good way to evaluate somebody’s spirituality, whether our own or somebody else’s. Saul was a really authentic enemy of God. Somebody else can spend all day long gushing about God’s goodness, yet be at best misled and at worst a hypocrite. We ourselves can be 100 percent convinced that our feet are on the path to heaven, yet be 100 percent wrong.
Instead, if we want to learn the truth, we have to turn to the time-honored pastime of fruit inspection. We learn who people are by what they do. Somebody who loves God will keep His commandments, and nothing but love can provide the motivation for an obedient life. Faithfulness reveals the truth, both without and within.
You want to indict Christians or churches for hypocrisy? Fine. You want to criticize them for loving tradition more than the Bible? Go ahead. You want to condemn them for Malachi 1 apathy? Sure. However, recognize that all of these are fundamentally obedience problems, and they are measured by the word.
On the other hand, saying that somebody cares more about the rules than they do about God is logically incoherent. Failure to emote appropriately is not a spiritual problem. Some people simply aren’t emoters. I preached both of my parents’ funerals without a single catch in my voice or a single tear. If you want to conclude that I didn’t love my parents, you’re at liberty to do so, I guess.
Rather than pointing to a spiritual weakness, concern with obedience points to a spiritual strength. People who truly do want to get everything right in their service to God are people who care about God and are committed to Him. That might not read as authentic, but it’s as real as godliness gets.
Abortion: A Biblical Perspective
Wednesday, November 13, 2019Another week, another requested sermon! This one comes from Charlie, who suggested in an elder-evangelist meeting a couple of months ago that I ought to preach a sermon on abortion. He observed, and I think correctly, that nearly every Christian has heard and believes that abortion is wrong, but also that few of us have worked through the Biblical logic for ourselves.
It’s important for us to do that. Certainly, abortion is a politically significant issue in our country, but I’m not presenting this lesson because I think it’s my place to tell Christians how to vote. Instead, my role is to tell Christians how to look at the world through God’s eyes. This isn’t primarily a voting-booth issue. It’s a real-life issue. Is abortion an option for women of God? How do we discuss this topic with others? How should the Scriptures inform the way we treat women who may be considering an abortion or even who have had one? These are critical questions. Let’s see how we should answer them as we consider abortion from a Biblical perspective.
The first Biblical principle that should inform our understanding is that EVERY LIFE MATTERS. Let’s begin here by considering the creation account of Genesis 1:26-27. This, brethren, is the foundation of everything the Bible says about how we should treat others. God is a being of infinite worth, every human being is created in the image and likeness of God, so every human being is a being of infinite worth too. Really, the whole New Testament is nothing more than the working out of this great truth. Being a Christian means being committed to the idea that everybody matters.
This includes not only people outside of the womb, but people inside it. The Scriptures make clear that people have identity and personhood before they are born. Look, for instance, at what God tells Jeremiah in Jeremiah 1:4-5. Even before he was born, Jeremiah was still Jeremiah. Even before any of us were born, we were still us, and all of us were and are precious image-bearers of God.
One of the great big moral problems with abortion is that it doesn’t treat people equally. Babies whom the mother wants to carry to term are precious image-bearers. In fact, if you kill a pregnant woman in Tennessee, they will charge you with double murder. However, if the mother doesn’t want to carry that baby to term, suddenly it doesn’t have value. It becomes the mother, rather than God, who assigns worth to that baby.
Worldwide, this has had horrific consequences. For instance, did you know that in Iceland these days, no more babies are being born with Down’s Syndrome? That’s because all of them are being detected during pregnancy screening and aborted. I think that’s horrible! Sure, people with Down’s Syndrome are often not as capable in some ways, but all of them whom I have known have had a kind, gracious spirit that would do credit to any Christian. Even more fundamentally, every one of them is created in the image of God too, and nobody should have the right to judge them as being unworthy.
Second, the Bible should call us to, for lack of a better way of expressing it, HUMILITY WITH LIFE. Consider what the Scriptures report about God in Psalm 90:1-4. God is so much greater than we are, and when it comes to matters of life and death, His decisions are so much greater than we are too.
This is something that I really got for the first time after my daughter Macy died. As I’m sure you can imagine, I spent years thinking long and deeply about it, trying to figure out what it all meant. On the one hand, losing a child was a horrendous experience, but on the other, that horrendous experience also equipped me to comfort others.
I think that for most people, having one of your children die is unimaginable. For me, I don’t even have to imagine. Others don’t know how it feels or what to say. I do. And so, for the past 10 years, as I’ve had opportunity, I’ve been saying it. Most notably, that helped me to reach out to a brother named Dennis and literally talk him out of killing himself. The tragic center of his tragic life was that he had lost a child too, and because we could meet each other there, I think I could help him find some peace.
As a human being, how do you deal with that? How do you balance your daughter’s life against being able to save somebody else’s life? When I confront that question, every time, I’m forced to turn away. I’m not big enough to answer it. However, I believe that God is big enough to answer it. In His greatness, He can judge in matters of life and death, and His judgments are always right.
This understanding is really at the heart of my objections to abortion. Abortion is wrong because it takes the power of life and death and arrogates that to ourselves. Even in cases where God expressly delegates that power to humankind, as with capital punishment, I think most of us would agree that we don’t do a great job making those decisions. We aren’t built for it. How much more, then, is making that decision about an unborn child beyond any of us?
However, we must balance that moral realization with COMPASSION FOR OTHERS. Here, let’s begin with what the Hebrews writer says about priests under the Law of Moses in Hebrews 5:1-2. I love this passage because it shows us that when we address the frailties of others, the first step must be to consider our own frailty.
It is awfully easy to demonize women who have abortions, but that is the very thing that a Christian must never do. There’s this portrait floating around out there of trashy women who have abortions because pregnancy is an inconvenience to their love lives, but I think that portrait bears almost no resemblance to reality.
Instead, I think that 99 percent of the time, women who have abortions, have them because they are afraid, in fact, because they’re terrified. They’re afraid of not being able to keep the job they depend on to live. They’re afraid that their boyfriend is going to leave them once he finds out they’re pregnant. They’re afraid that their church is going to find out and spend the next 50 years gossiping about them.
I sympathize with the brethren who are politically active because they want to see Roe v. Wade overturned. I think that their hearts are right, but I am less certain that their actions will have the effect that they want. Even if abortion is totally outlawed in our country (and I’m skeptical that will ever happen, honestly), all that will accomplish is to drive it underground again. Women who are afraid enough to abort their babies are also afraid enough to break the law to do it.
Instead, if we want to attack abortion, we must attack the fear that underlies it. Be somebody who is willing to care for a child not your own, so that women know they have options. Be somebody who will support and encourage single moms in a life that is very difficult instead of sneering at them and blaming them for their predicament.
For that matter, be somebody who is gentle with sinners rather than gossipy and harsh. Yes, they need to repent, but that’s for their sake, not ours. We need to make sure that everybody knows this church is a home for forgiven sinners, because that’s all any of us are.
Summary: Psalm 119:33-112
Tuesday, November 12, 2019As with everything else in the psalm, this section of Psalm 119 concerns the relationship between the psalmist and the word of God. The acrostic structure of the psalm continues in this portion, this time employing the Hebrew letters from He to Nun.
Psalm 119:33-40 (He) acknowledges the connection between God’s word and life. Those who seek the word and follow it will receive life, but those who seek after worthless things and selfish gain will not know God’s blessing.
Psalm 119:41-48 (Waw) focuses particular attention on the usefulness of the word in times of confrontation. The psalmist uses the law of God to answer those who taunt him, to find hope, and to give him confidence when he stands before kings. These benefits are only available to those who love God’s commandments and trust in them.
Psalm 119:49-56 (Zayin) considers the consolation that is available in the word. Even when he is afflicted, when others mock him, when the wicked abandon God, and when things look (both literally and metaphorically) dark, the psalmist still draws comfort from God’s law.
Psalm 119:57-64 (Heth) makes a connection between the steadfastness of God and the psalmist’s steadfastness. No matter what, he continues to seek the word and praise God, and he is confident that this is the correct strategy because of the obviousness of God’s steadfast love.
Psalm 119:65-72 (Teth) explores the difference between those who honor God’s law and those who do not. The psalmist strayed from God before he was afflicted, but his suffering taught him the importance of obedience. On the other hand, the insolent continue to oppose him and God because the word does not move their hearts.
Psalm 119:73-80 (Yodh) examines the value of the word in times of trouble. Through God and His law, the psalmist hopes that his affliction will work out for good, that he will be comforted, that the insolent will be ashamed, and that the faithful will seek him out.
Psalm 119:81-88 (Kaph) is a plea for God’s help according to the promises of the word. The psalmist has lived according to God’s law, and he cherishes the hope that God offers him. Consequently, he calls on God to rescue him so that his relationship with His commandments can continue.
Psalm 119:89-96 (Lamedh) focuses on the trustworthiness of the word. The rest of God’s creation proclaims His faithfulness, so it is logical to attribute that same faithfulness to the word. Those who trust in it will be delivered.
Psalm 119:97-104 (Mem) is one of the most famous sections of the psalm. It exclaims over the psalmist’s love for God’s law and the benefits that come from studying it. The commandments of God make the psalmist wiser than mentors and enemies alike, and they teach him to act and think righteously.
Psalm 119:105-112 (Nun) contains the most famous verse in the psalm (119:105) and reflects further on how the word is useful through different seasons of life. The psalmist vows his faithfulness to the word until life’s end.